Baked from scratch on premises at our Upper East Side and Midtown East shops, for pickup or delivery across NYC.
Search for a favorite or start with the occasion.
Loved on Google, Yelp and Nextdoor by our Upper East Side and Midtown neighbors.
Read ReviewsGluten-free and vegan cakes made to order. Please note our kitchen is not nut-free.
See Our RangeAll-natural ingredients, baked to order on premises at both of our NYC shops.
Visit UsHoliday Specials
Pies, seasonal cakes and dessert boxes for your table. Order early for pickup or delivery.
Catering
Edible logo cookies, branded cupcakes and dessert platters for launches, client gifts and office celebrations.
Indulge in New York's Finest Customizable Cake Collection
Browse by occasion or style. Any design can change colors, just ask.
Choose your size, cake flavor and filling.
Choose a location at checkout. Most cakes need 48–72 hours.
Famous desserts and little sweets, baked fresh every morning.
Beyond our delicious desserts and freshly baked goods, we also provide savory sandwiches, smoothies, fresh juices and a wide variety of Illy’s hot and cold beverages. So whether you’re stopping for your morning coffee, lunch, or afternoon snack, we have you covered!


Copyright © 2026 Crumbly Cafe & Bakery - All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy.